UPS Loses a Round in Court

The Mail Box Etc. conversion to UPS Stores continues to generate bad PR for UPS. Mail Box Etc. stores were generating a living for most franchisees, but the UPS Stores emphasize UPS shipping services where the margins are very low.   This was not a ruling on whether UPS misled the franchisees, but just a procedural ruling permitting the case to go to forward with a hearing on the merits.

United Parcel Service Inc. franchisees have won the right to sue the world’s largest package shipping firm as
a group over claims it misled them by saying that converting their Mail Boxes Etc. stores into UPS Stores would be more profitable.

“This is a huge win,” said Howard Spanier, a Malibu, Calif., franchisee who said he converted his store last year, according to a statement Friday. The class action was certified Wednesday by a California appeals court, overturning a trial court ruling rejecting the franchisees’ request.

UPS, based in Sandy Springs, is accused of withholding critical documents about tests of the UPS Store business model it conducted in several U.S. cities. The franchisees claim the conversion was “disastrous” for some of the stores.

Similar Posts:

Article by Ryan Knoll

Ryan is an attorney and valuation specialist residing in Chicago. He chronicles his thoughts and research on FranchisePundit.com. You may reach him by email ryanknoll@gmail.com or mobile telephone 312-715-8115. Read 448 articles by
It's very calm over here, why not leave a comment?

Leave a Reply




RSS Discussion Forum

  • Re: De-Identify February 7, 2012
    There are several issues here.1)   Ethics – though your franchisor may not have lived up to your expectations if they are meeting the letter of the law then I am not sure you have the moral upperhand.  If you signed on to pay and advertising fee without... […]
  • Re: De-Identify February 5, 2012
    it would be leaving early..Its a Franchise that has lost over 30 units in the past few years. and is not living up to what we bought into.. advertising fee's are not being used on anything for the franchisee. and there is no support from the franchise... […]
  • Re: De-Identify February 4, 2012
    Quote from: jerichox on February 01, 2012, 08:27:34 AMJust wondering if you guys think its a smart idea for a franchisee to de-identify his store? Also.. Franchises normally have a list of items that need to be changed to the color of ... […]
  • De-Identify February 1, 2012
    Just wondering if you guys think its a smart idea for a franchisee to de-identify his store? Also.. Franchises normally have a list of items that need to be changed to the color of the walls to the lights that hang.. How would you go about doing this.... […]
  • Re: franchise directory January 8, 2012
    Remember if  you approach a franchisor and that franchisor uses brokers you should be able to reduce your franchise fee by the price of the commision they would pay to a broker.    You have bargaining power before you sign the FA not after!!!!Moreover... […]

Blog Categories

Old Posts